
Subject Matter Experts: Elevate Your Training Collaboration
Learning Design / Collaboration
Working with Subject Matter Experts. Turning expertise into useful learning.
The expert knows the work. The learning designer helps uncover what the learner actually needs from it.
Subject Matter Experts are essential to good learning design. But effective collaboration is not simply asking an expert to “send us the content”.
Knows the work.
Technical knowledge, operational experience, exceptions, risks, decisions and the realities of doing the job.
Shapes the learning.
Identifies what matters, structures the experience and turns expertise into something another person can understand and use.
The Partnership
Expertise alone isn't the finished learning solution.
Subject Matter Experts bring knowledge that a learning designer cannot simply reproduce from a textbook or specification.
They understand the work, the exceptions, the difficult decisions and often the small details that make the difference between understanding a process and actually performing it.
The learning designer's job is to help surface that expertise, decide what matters to the learner and turn it into an appropriate learning experience.
From Expertise To Learning
There is a journey between “knowing” and “teaching”.
The useful part of the SME's expertise needs to be uncovered, organised and connected to what somebody must actually do.
Expertise
What does the SME know from experience?
Tasks
What does the learner actually have to do?
Decisions
Where does judgement or interpretation matter?
Practice
What needs to be experienced rather than simply explained?
Learning
What will help someone perform successfully?
Start Well
Five things make SME collaboration work better.
Build trust first
SMEs need to know their expertise is valued. Taking time to understand their role, background and preferred way of working creates a much stronger foundation for collaboration.
Be clear about the roles
Agree who owns subject accuracy, learning design, approvals, timelines and decisions before the project becomes complicated.
Elicit knowledge
Don't just ask for slides or documents. Use conversations, demonstrations, examples, observation and task walkthroughs to uncover how the work actually happens.
Manage expectations
Be clear about scope, review points, availability and timescales. Regular communication makes surprises much less likely.
Review with purpose
Ask SMEs to review technical accuracy, operational realism and important exceptions rather than simply asking, “What do you think?”
Clear Roles
Collaboration works better when everyone knows what they own.
The SME and learning designer bring different expertise to the same problem.
Owns the subject.
- Technical and operational accuracy
- Real-world tasks and procedures
- Critical exceptions and edge cases
- Examples from practice
- Safety or compliance considerations
Owns the learning process.
- Performance and learning analysis
- Learning objectives
- Structure and sequencing
- Choice of modality and practice
- Learner experience and cognitive load
Knowledge Elicitation
Better questions uncover better learning.
Experts often perform parts of their job almost automatically. Asking only “What does someone need to know?” can miss much of the judgement that sits behind good performance.
“Talk me through what you actually do.”
Start with the task rather than the content.
“Where do people usually struggle?”
Experts often know where mistakes or misunderstandings occur.
“How do you know what to do next?”
This can uncover hidden decisions, cues and professional judgement.
“What changes when things don't go to plan?”
Exceptions can be more valuable to learning than the perfect process.
“Can you show me?”
Demonstration, observation and job shadowing can surface things that are difficult to explain in conversation.
A Useful Filter
Interesting isn't always necessary.
An SME may know a huge amount about the subject. The learner does not necessarily need all of it.
Everything around the subject.
History, context, specialist detail, exceptions, background knowledge and years of accumulated expertise.
What supports successful performance.
The right knowledge, decisions, practice and reference material to perform the task safely and effectively.
Does the learner need to know this to perform the task?
Review With Purpose
“What do you think?” is usually too broad.
SMEs are much more useful reviewers when they know what kind of feedback is needed.
Instead of inviting a complete redesign at every review point, ask them to focus on subject accuracy, operational realism, missing exceptions and anything that could create misunderstanding.
The learning designer can then make informed decisions about structure, language, sequencing and learner experience.
Manage Expectations
Good collaboration needs a little structure.
SME availability is often limited because being the expert is usually not their only job.
Scope
Agree what the project is — and what it isn't.
Time
Make SME input visible in the plan rather than assuming it will appear.
Reviews
Agree when reviews happen and what each review is intended to check.
Decisions
Be clear about who makes the final call when views differ.
The Partnership
The best learning is built together.
Strong SME relationships are not just useful because they make projects easier to manage.
They give learning designers access to the reality of the work: what matters, where people struggle, how experienced practitioners make decisions and what successful performance actually looks like.
The goal isn't to capture everything the expert knows.
It is to identify what somebody else needs to know, practise or decide in order to perform well.
The SME brings the expertise. The learning designer turns it into performance.
Learning Design
Understand first. Create second.
Good learning doesn't start with a blank Storyline file, a Rise template or a predetermined classroom session.
It starts with understanding the work, the performance problem and the people who know that work best.
Complex Subject Matter?
Start by understanding the work.
If you have the experts but need help turning their knowledge into clear, useful learning, WH Collective can help shape the right learning response.